Professional judgment
In plain words
Professional judgment is the authority federal law gives a college's financial aid administrator to adjust your FAFSA information or cost of attendance, one case at a time, for a documented reason.
A letter or an aid office page may say the school can use professional judgment to take another look at your aid. Here you can see what that authority covers, what stays fixed, and how to put a request in front of the person who decides.
What the authority covers
Federal law lets the aid administrator at each school make changes for one student at a time when the standard form does not describe that student's situation well. The administrator can adjust items that feed the Student Aid Index, such as income, or adjust parts of the cost of attendance, such as dependent care or disability-related costs. The same authority covers decisions about dependency in unusual cases.
The formula itself stays the same for everyone. What changes are the figures that go into it, and only with a reason the school can document and keep on file.
Who decides and how final it is
The decision belongs to the school. An administrator can approve a request, approve part of it or turn it down, and no rule requires a change. The Department of Education does not review these decisions, so a denial cannot be appealed there.
A school may offer its own second look, such as a review by the aid director or a committee. Ask whether one exists and how to request it. A different school can reach a different decision on the same facts, because each one applies its own judgment.
The Department of Education does not review these decisions, so a denial cannot be appealed there.
Putting in a request
Many schools post a form called a special circumstances request or an appeal form on the aid office pages. Write a short, factual account of what changed and when, and attach documents that show it. A request without documents usually cannot move forward.
Send the request as soon as you know of the change, since some aid is limited and handed out as the year goes on. Keep a copy, note the date you sent it, and ask how long a decision usually takes.
How it may be printed
- professional judgment
- PJ
- PJ request
- adjustment request
What you can do this week
- Ask the aid office whether it has a written request form
- Write down what changed and the dates
- Gather documents that show the change
- Ask how and when the decision will be sent
Who to ask
The financial aid administrator at your school
Worth remembering. Professional judgment lets one school adjust your figures for a documented reason, and that school's decision is final.